Topic
ODIHR Legal Reviews, Assessments
Variety of useful resources and tools prepared by ODIHR to support legal reform in OSCE participating States. It includes legal reviews of draft and exisiting national legislation and assessments of legislative process.
Opinions
El Dictamen señala que los tribunales constitucionales o instituciones equivalentes, facultadas para efectuar la revisión de la constitucionalidad, desempeñan un papel clave para garantizar que los principios del Estado de Derecho, la democracia y los derechos humanos se respeten en todas las instituciones estatales. Se reconoce la importancia y la necesidad de encontrar una solución al estancamiento, especialmente cuando se trata de nombramientos para una institución clave, aunque cualquier solución legislativa debe cumplir con el principio de seguridad jurídica y no debe ser utilizada para eludir las salvaguardas existentes y las disposiciones constitucionales, incluyendo las destinadas a asegurar el consenso entre las distintas fuerzas políticas. El presente Dictamen recomienda revisar el sistema de propuesta de nombramiento de los miembros del Tribunal Constitucional para garantizar que el proceso de nominación incluya controles y equilibrios adecuados, permita el ejercicio equilibrado del poder de todas las autoridades nominadoras y sea el resultado de un proceso abierto y transparente respaldado por criterios claros y objetivos que aseguren una selección basada en el mérito. También es fundamental que cualquier esfuerzo futuro de reforma aborde la cuestión del nombramiento de doce jueces miembros del CGPJ para garantizar que ya no sea efectuado por el Parlamento sino por el Poder Judicial, puesto que el riesgo de estancamiento no se puede abordar adecuadamente si el CGPJ está o puede estar potencialmente sujeto a la influencia política.
The Opinion notes that Constitutional courts or comparable institutions empowered with constitutional review play a key role to ensure that the principles of the rule of law, democracy and human rights are observed in all state institutions. The importance and need to find a solution to a stalemate, especially when it concerns appointments to a key institution is recognized, though any legislative solutions should comply with the principle of legal certainty, and not be used to circumvent existing safeguards and constitutional provisions, including those designed to ensure consensus between the different political forces. The Opinion recommends that the modalities of nomination of members of the Constitutional Court should be reviewed to ensure that the nomination process includes adequate checks and balances, allows a power-balanced role of all nominating authorities and is the result of an open and transparent process underpinned by clear and objective criteria ensuring a merit-based selection. It is also fundamental that any future reform efforts address the issue of appointment of twelve judge members of the GCJ to ensure that it is no longer carried out by the Parliament but rather by the judiciary since the risk of stalemate cannot be properly addressed if the GCJ is or can potentially be subject to political influence.
Comments
No documents
Notes
No documents
Others
No documents
Legislation
Constitution
Variety of useful resources and tools prepared by ODIHR to support legal reform in OSCE participating States. It includes legal reviews of draft and exisiting national legislation and assessments of legislative process.
Most read documents
Legislation
Criminal codes
National legislative acts on a range of human dimension issues. It offers access to full-text documents, as well as summaries of and excerpts from national constitutions, primary and secondary legislation and case-law from across the OSCE region.
Legislation
Primary and Secondary
National legislative acts on a range of human dimension issues. It offers access to full-text documents, as well as summaries of and excerpts from national constitutions, primary and secondary legislation and case-law from across the OSCE region.
Most read documents
International standards
National legislative acts on a range of human dimension issues. It offers access to full-text documents, as well as summaries of and excerpts from national constitutions, primary and secondary legislation and case-law from across the OSCE region.
Most read documents
No documents
Case-law
Case law subline. Status of Ratification of the Main International Human Rights Treaties, Conventions and other instruments. International Case-law for selected topics.
National
No documents